Knit Picks Reviews

Knit Picks has an overall rating of 4.7 based on 30 reviews. Customer feedback on Knit Picks is mixed: Knit Picks reviewers highlight positive aspects like wide selection of yarns, competitive pricing, excellent customer service, user-friendly website, which strongly appeal to knitting and crochet enthusiasts, hobbyists, crafters, and DIY lovers. However, Knit Picks is often criticized for its shipping delays, occasional quality inconsistencies, limited physical store presence, higher prices on some items.

4.7/5.0

30 reviews

5 Stars

20

4 Stars

9

3 Stars

0

2 Stars

0

1 Star

0

All Knit Picks Reviews (30)
RoyTripp
May 31, 2026
"Everything arrived just right"
My order showed up with every skein and needle exactly as requested, with no mix-ups at all. It definitely gave me confidence ordering from them again
loishansberger8976
May 18, 2026
"Checkout was easy overall"
Checkout was smooth for the most part, honestly. The only thing is the coupon box took me a minute to spot, so that could be a little easier to find.
yvette.Rocha
May 04, 2026
"Super Soft Yarn, Really Pleased"
I ordered a few skeins from KnitPicks and I’m really happy with them. The yarn feels so soft while I’m knitting, and it doesn’t have that scratchy feel at all. The colors looked nice too, but the softness is what stood out to me the most. I’d definitely buy it again, especially for sweaters.
GlennJohnson_38
May 02, 2026
"Super Easy Patterns!!"
I’ve been really happy with these patterns!! They’re clear, easy to follow, and I haven’t run into any issues at all
john_Turner70
May 01, 2026
"Always Has What I’m Looking For"
They had the stuff I needed in stock, which makes the whole trip easy. Nothing complicated, if you go to a store, you expect them to have the basics, and they did.
Clyde_lyons91
April 26, 2026
"Pretty happy with this yarn"
I grabbed a few skeins i was pleased with them. There was only one tiny join that I noticed, and it was easy enough to work around. It felt soft, the colors looked close to the photos, and it just worked out nicely for my project. No real complaints here, I’d buy it again.
Jeremy-lasch
April 15, 2026
"I reached out to support and they got..."
I reached out to support and they got back to me quickly. Compared to other places where you end up waiting forever, this was a nice change. They understood the issue and had it sorted without much hassle.
HEATH
April 09, 2026
"Finally, a listing that actually matches the product"
It was exactly as shown, which shouldn’t feel like such a rare thing these days, but here we are. The description was spot on, no weird surprises, no misleading photos, no “well technically” nonsense. Just what I ordered and what I expected.
richard-Madison
April 05, 2026
"Yarn’s held up well so far"
I’ve ordered from Knit Picks a handful of times, mostly for a few random projects, and the yarn has been really decent. I made a sweater last winter with one of them and it’s been through the wash a bunch already. It’s not falling apart or getting all thin and weird, which is what I was hoping for. There’s a little pilling, but nothing out of the ordinary, at least in my experience. For the price, I’ve been happy with it and I’ll probably keep buying from them.
Lonnie.manning
March 30, 2026
"My sweater kit arrived with everything I needed..."
My sweater kit arrived with everything I needed, including the yarn and pattern. I even checked it against my order email/receipt, and nothing was missing. It made it really easy to just sit down and get started.
stephanie_Brown94
March 18, 2026
"I didn’t overthink it, if the needles feel smooth..."
I didn’t overthink it—if the needles feel smooth and the tools don’t feel flimsy, that’s usually good enough for me. These passed that quick gut-check. The needles glide nicely, and the tools feel solid enough for regular use.
Christina.dalton
March 08, 2026
"Colors were pretty much what I expected"
I ordered a few skeins from KnitPicks and was actually relieved that the colors looked almost the same as they did online. I’ve had yarn show up looking totally different before, so I was kind of bracing myself for that.

The blue looked maybe a tiny bit darker once I had it in my room, but that’s probably just my lighting. The rest were really close, even the soft pink shade, which I was a little nervous about. I did feel a bit dismissed when I had asked a question beforehand and got a generic answer, though.

Still, the colors themselves made the whole process a lot less stressful. I’d order again based on that alone, even if the customer service side could have felt a little more personal.
hello_david374
March 05, 2026
"Nice yarn for the price, dye lots matched well enough"
I picked up a few skeins from KnitPicks for a sweater, and I was trying to keep the cost reasonable, so I didn’t want to overbuy at first. Of course, I ended up needing more yarn later and got a little nervous about whether the dye lot would be way off.

The second batch was really close. If I look super carefully I can tell it’s not a perfect match, but once it was knitted in, it blended in just fine. I do wish it were easier to get the exact same lot later, but for the price, I’m happy with how it turned out. 4 stars.
avis-Sampson
February 18, 2026
"I’ve had a good experience so far..."
I’ve had a good experience so far. When the sales pop up, the discounts are actually worth checking out, and I’ve found a few better deals here than on some competing sites. Checkout was simple enough and didn’t feel like a hassle
stephan.Mitchell
February 13, 2026
"I’ve ordered from KnitPicks a handful of..."
I’ve ordered from KnitPicks a handful of times now, the prices feel like a small miracle compared to what I’d pay at some of my local yarn shops. The yarn has been solid quality, and I don’t get that tragic little feeling that I’ve just emptied my wallet for one project. Shipping has been totally fine too. It’s become my go-to when I’m planning a bigger knit and don’t want my budget to collapse in a dramatic heap.
Judith_val80
February 01, 2026
"Honestly, this yarn is way better than it needs to be"
I’ve ordered yarn from KnitPicks a few times now, and seriously, why is it this good for the price? It’s soft, the colors are actually in person, and I haven’t run into any of those annoying random knots yet, which feels like a small miracle. It works up nice and even too, so I’m not sitting there fighting with it the whole time. i’m really happy with it and will absolutely keep ordering.
RichardGriffith_36
February 01, 2026
"Such an easy, stress-free exchange"
I was so relieved by how simple the exchange was. The return went through quickly, and there was no frustrating back-and-forth or hassle at all. It felt really smooth and painless.
lucille1974
January 31, 2026
"Refund went smoothly"
I had to send back part of my order because I chose the wrong yarn color, which was totally on me. The refund didn’t show up right away, so I got a little nervous at first — well, not nervous exactly, just unsure what was going on.
Customer service got back to me after a couple of days and took care of it. The money came through after that, so while it wasn’t super fast, it was fair and hassle-free.
avisturk0353
January 20, 2026
"My yarn showed up in really good shape..."
My yarn showed up in really good shape, and the box wasn’t banged up or anything. Everything was tucked in neatly, with no odd smells or damaged labels. I know shipping can be hit or miss and not everything is always in the seller’s control, but in this case they clearly did their part. It’s a small thing, but I really appreciated it.
Joanie.kurtz
January 18, 2026
"Nice yarn, but the shipping made me blink"
I’ve ordered from KnitPicks a handful of times now, i’ve always been happy with the yarn. The colors and quality have been good, and my order showed up in decent time with no issues. Then I got to the shipping cost and suddenly I was emotionally staring out a window like I’d been betrayed. It just feels a little high if you’re only grabbing a couple things. I’d probably order more often for small projects if shipping was cheaper, but overall I’m still happy with what I’ve bought.

View More Reviews

Have a question about Knit Picks?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.